Colleagues gathered in a group – second victim, when the professional is affected by an error

Second victim – when the professional becomes the second victim of an error

After her shift, a nurse discovers that a patient has been given the wrong dose of medication. The patient recovers, but the nurse cannot let it go. She lies awake at night, going over the shift again and again. She does not really dare tell her colleagues, because what will they think?

 

Most professionals are conscientious and do their best. Even so, errors happen, because of time pressure, a lack of knowledge or circumstances nobody had control over. When an error harms another person, it also hits the professional who made it. Here you can read what second victim means, why the workplace’s response is crucial, and how you can handle errors so that both people and learning are taken seriously.

 

Second victim is one of the concepts we describe in A Handbook on Psychological Well-being. In it, we look at how workplaces can talk about errors in a way that both protects professionals and strengthens learning.

What does second victim mean?

The first victim is the patient, citizen or client harmed by the error. The second victim is the professional who was involved.

 

The term is used because professionals are typically deeply shaken by having made an error that affected another person’s wellbeing. That is why the professional must also be seen as someone who has been affected, and not only as the person responsible.

 

This does not mean that the error does not matter or that no one is responsible. It means that responsibility must be placed correctly, and that the professional affected needs support.

Why do errors hit so hard?

Errors are harder to live with when they have had serious consequences for another person. On top of that, a number of factors can make the strain greater:

 

  • Guilt and self-reproach. Many people go over the incident again and again, asking themselves what they should have done differently.
  • Fear of what others think. Few people like admitting a mistake. Many would rather hide it, just as after a belly flop you make sure to hide the red skin under your clothes.
  • Complaints and cases. A formal complaint is stressful, regardless of whether an error has actually occurred. Long case processing times make it worse.
  • Fear of being publicly shamed. The thought of being described in the press or online as a professional who does not know their limits can be a heavy burden.

Second victim blaming: when the organisation makes things worse

When we see others fail, we are quick to explain it by their personality or lack of ability. When we fail ourselves, we explain it by the circumstances. Psychology calls this the fundamental attribution error. It applies to organisations too.

 

If the workplace looks only at the person who made the error, and not at the conditions that contributed to it, two things happen. The workplace loses the opportunity to learn from the error. And it becomes guilty of what is called second victim blaming: the professional affected is blamed for something that was also about work routines, staffing, time pressure and organisation. This is an additional risk factor for the person who made the error.

 

Hindsight also plays a part. Afterwards, it is easy to see what should have been done. But many of the choices that led to a poor outcome were reasonable given what the professional knew at the time. Sometimes it is not an error at all, but conditions nobody could influence. It can be easier to feel guilty than to accept that you work in a complex reality where much cannot be controlled. But then you are powerless, not guilty.

From the individual to the whole team

Many workplaces have already shifted their focus. A midwife describes it like this: in the past, the focus was on the individual midwife who might have misheard something. Today, the focus is on the whole team and its work routines.

 

That is what it takes. When a complex error occurs, it is rarely one person’s fault. It typically arises from an unfortunate interplay of many factors. That is why it also holds learning for the whole organisation, including the health and safety committee.

 

Luck also plays a part. Good planning increases the chance of a good outcome but can never guarantee it. A work group that remembers this avoids mistaking bad luck for a lack of ability.

How the workplace can provide support

When an error has occurred, two things are needed at the same time: support for the professional affected and a thorough examination of what happened.

 

Support the professional. Colleagues and managers can reach out, listen and show that they understand. The professional should not be left alone with the blame. Read more about social support in the workplace.

 

Examine the conditions, not just the person. Look at work routines, staffing, information and collaboration. Ask what made the error possible rather than who made it.

 

Be aware of hindsight. Ask what the professional knew in the situation, not only what is known now.

 

Follow up over time. A complaint case can drag on. The person affected needs support for as long as the case is ongoing, not just in the days afterwards.

 

Arrange professional help when it is needed. If reactions persist or get worse, help from a psychologist may be needed. Read more about signs of psychological overload.

Psychological safety makes it possible to talk about errors

Groups where it is not safe to talk about errors tend to hide and under-report them. Then they learn nothing, and those who made the errors are left alone with them.

 

In a group with psychological safety it is possible to say: “I have made a mistake.” It is also possible to share small concerns early, before they grow big. Many complex errors could have been avoided if someone had spoken up in time.

 

An error can be seen as an investment the workplace has already paid for. It would be foolish not to reap the learning.

 

The Institute for Strain Psychology helps workplaces build a culture where errors can be handled openly. Read more about our workplace health and safety courses.

Digital implementation courses for professionals in psychologically demanding work

Foundation Course in Strain Psychology

For a holistic approach to managing everyday high emotional demands and exposure to potentially traumatic events.

Foundation Course in Psychological First Aid

For collective crisis response when something unexpected happens — and the group must manage an extraordinary psychological strain together.

Foundation Course in Psychological Safety

Ensuring that tools and methods truly work in practice — rather than remaining well-written policies in contingency plans.

Foundation Course in Psychosocial Prevention

Creating a shared understanding of what proactive, collective prevention looks like in daily practice.

Q&A: Second victim

Second victim is the term for the professional involved in an error that harmed a patient, citizen or client. The professional is typically deeply shaken and also needs support.

When an organisation looks only at the person who made the error and not at the conditions that contributed to it. This places an extra burden on the professional affected, and the organisation loses the chance to learn.

Any professional whose work affects other people’s lives and health, such as healthcare staff, social workers, educators and police officers. The term is used especially in healthcare.

No. It means that responsibility must be placed correctly. An error rarely happens because of one person alone. Work routines, staffing and organisation also play a part.

Offer support, examine the conditions surrounding the error rather than only the person, be aware of hindsight, and follow up for as long as any complaint case is ongoing.