Drawing of a work group around a table where everyone takes part – psychological safety and leadership

The leader's role in psychological safety – setting the frame, curiosity and the courage to step in

A newly hired doctor discovers that blood test results and ECGs are being overlooked in the department. Colleagues confirm that it happens often. The doctor spends free time drafting a proposal for a better procedure and puts it on the agenda for the staff meeting. But the manager quickly cuts in: there is already a procedure, so that was a short item. Next item.

 

The situation takes less than a minute, but it teaches everyone in the room something about what happens when you speak up. Psychological Safety is the belief that you will not be punished or humiliated for coming forward with ideas, questions, concerns or mistakes. Everyone in a group helps create it, but the leader has a special role. Here you can read why leadership matters so much for psychological safety, and what leaders can actually do.

Why does the leader have a special role in psychological safety?

Leaders are role models, whether they want to be or not. Psychological safety is something you do, not something you can agree your way to. Employees notice how the leader reacts when someone asks a critical question or reports a mistake.

 

One of the fastest routes to more safety in a group is a leader who dares to share their own doubts, gaps in knowledge and mistakes. One senior manager describes going to their management team and saying: I have gone too far down the wrong path, and I need your help to get back. It became one of the best processes that manager has been part of.

 

For many leaders this can feel unsafe. The traditional leadership values have been strength, decisiveness and certainty. Today they are increasingly combined with values such as openness, doubt and curiosity. In our A Handbook on Psychological Well-being we prefer to call it humanity rather than vulnerability, because it better describes what it is about: a leader who is at ease with the fact that no one can know everything.

The pitfall: "It's already so safe here"

Many leaders overestimate the safety in their group. They experience that people can simply say what they think, and that there is therefore no need to invite more input. But the leader judges safety from their own experience, and the leader is part of what makes the room more or less safe for employees.

 

Most leaders have a leader of their own. Think of a management meeting where you felt unsafe. What could your own leader have done to make it easier for you to speak up? The answer often says a lot about what your own employees need.

Set the frame for the work

The leader's tasks can be summed up in three: setting the frame, inviting participation and responding constructively. The first is about everyone knowing what is expected and what the task involves.

 

Align expectations. What is realistic to achieve with the resources available? What should be deprioritised during sickness and vacant positions? This is a responsibility for the whole management chain. Psychological safety requires a realistic balance between ambitions and resources. Otherwise there is a risk of emotional stress, among both employees and leaders.

 

Talk about the risks of the task. In psychologically demanding professions it is normal to be affected by the work, and everyone has a point where it becomes too much. This needs to be said again and again. One leader describes sharing their own story with employees who have been badly shaken after hard assignments. That way they can hear that they are not the only ones, and that no one has to be a superhero.

 

Make it normal that mistakes can happen. Any treatment, case handling or call-out can go wrong. When the leader regularly says this out loud, it becomes easier to talk about mistakes and learn from them.

 

Remind the group of the purpose. In periods of extra high pressure it can help to remind the group who it is there for and why the work matters. The purpose can also serve as a guide when priorities have to be set.

Invite participation

Who wants to suggest something to a leader who seems to know everything? The second task is about making it easy for everyone to contribute.

 

Be curious. Open questions beginning with who, what, how or when give longer and more honest answers than questions that can be answered yes or no. A good rule when you hear something you believe is wrong: ask yourself, what if the other person is right?

 

Create fixed structures. Rounds at meetings where everyone says something make it easier to raise ideas, concerns and small mistakes before they grow large. It can also be a fixed round-up at the end of the week, where people can ask about anything they have been unsure of.

 

Solve tasks together. Many leaders also carry out professional tasks themselves. By bringing an employee along on the task, the leader shows that they need the employee's knowledge.

 

Some phrases that make it easier for others to contribute:

 

  • “Help me see what I have overlooked.”
  • “I’m unsure about …” or “I was wrong.”
  • “You look concerned. Let’s talk it through before we decide anything.”
  • “What professional concerns come up in relation to …?”

Respond constructively

The third task is about what the leader does when someone actually speaks up. The leader should thank people for all input, including bad news. This applies especially when someone reports a mistake with serious consequences. Then there is a need for a leader who can reassure, show care and see things in a wider perspective. One employee describes a leader who said: If there is a complaint about you, there is also a complaint about me, because I am the one with overall responsibility. That sentence put the employee at ease. Read also about second victim, when the professional is affected by a mistake.

 

Responding constructively also means stepping in against inappropriate behaviour, such as whispering in meetings, a condescending tone or a lack of help for colleagues. At the institute we often use this sentence: The culture of a workplace equals the worst behaviour the leader lets pass.

 

Many leaders find this the hardest part of the leadership role. There is a grey zone where you are unsure whether a comment was meant as a joke, and you may be afraid of the other person's reaction. But it creates safety when the leader makes sure the group's rules are kept. It creates insecurity when the leader turns a blind eye.

 

When the leader steps in, it is important to look at the cause behind the behaviour and not only at the person. Inappropriate behaviour in psychologically demanding professions is often linked to strain such as a heavy workload, conflicting demands or shocking experiences at work. It can also be about a lack of competencies, weak relationships in the group or unclear values. A calm, low-key question can open the conversation, for example: “I know it matters to you to be a good colleague. What do you feel you are up against at the moment?”

Leaders need safety too

Leaders react like everyone else when something threatens the group. One leader describes freezing when an employee began shaming a colleague in a meeting. The brain simply refused to understand what was happening.

 

That is why leaders cannot create psychological safety alone. They need expectations that match the resources, a leader who invites participation, and colleagues to talk through the difficult situations with. The leader's own safety and well-being are a precondition for being able to create safety for others. Read more about leader well-being, and about how we work with leaders’ well-being.

 

If you want to hear how an experienced leader works with this in practice, read the interview with Ann Rubæk-Nielsen, who has been a leader of leaders for 15 years.

 

The Institute for Strain Psychology helps leaders and work groups make psychological safety part of everyday work. Read more about our basic course in psychological well-being.

Digital implementation courses for professionals in psychologically demanding work

Foundation Course in Strain Psychology

For a holistic approach to managing everyday high emotional demands and exposure to potentially traumatic events.

Foundation Course in Psychological First Aid

For collective crisis response when something unexpected happens — and the group must manage an extraordinary psychological strain together.

Foundation Course in Psychological Safety

Ensuring that tools and methods truly work in practice — rather than remaining well-written policies in contingency plans.

Foundation Course in Psychosocial Prevention

Creating a shared understanding of what proactive, collective prevention looks like in daily practice.

Q&A: The leader’s role in psychological safety

The leader is a role model and has three central tasks: setting the frame for the work, inviting everyone to contribute, and responding constructively when someone comes forward with ideas, concerns or mistakes.

No. Psychological safety cannot be ordered. It grows out of what everyone in the group does towards each other. But the leader has great influence, because employees notice how the leader reacts.

It is about humanity. A leader who shares their doubts and mistakes and shows that no one can know everything makes it easier for others to do the same.

Because they judge safety from their own experience. For employees, the leader is part of what makes the room more or less safe.

Step in, even when you are unsure. Do it calmly and without exposing anyone, and look at the cause behind the behaviour. It is often linked to strain in the work or unclear expectations.