5 August The balance between being overinvolved or underinvolved
Professionals in high-risk mental jobs are, first and foremost, human beings—with a heartbeat, breath, and body warmth. We not only have the ability to empathize with others, but we often cannot help it due to our mirror neurons. The human nervous system is designed to automatically register the emotions and behaviors of others. “Perceive” might be a better term than “register,” because “register” implies conscious awareness, which is often not the case. Most of the information we pick up about others does not become conscious thought but is immediately translated into action—like walking down a busy street without bumping into anyone.
Mirror neurons
Our ability to perceive the emotions and behaviors of others is mediated by so-called mirror neurons. These are special cells in the brain that activate and allow us to internally simulate the state observed in another person. One could say our nervous systems automatically connect, similar to a device connecting to Wi-Fi without prior permission. Mirror neurons, in popular terms, can make emotions contagious and, through empathetic resonance, give us the ability to “read” others and empathize with their joys and sorrows. Without mirror neurons, we could not be empathetic or create strong shared moments with others.
Of course, these automatic mirroring processes are not always purely beneficial in high-risk mental jobs, where the neurobiological imprint of the person being helped often involves intense and painful emotions. The “front side” of mirror neurons is that they allow professionals to be empathetic and engaged. The “back side” is that they expose the professional to being overwhelmed by painful emotions, potentially short-circuiting their ability to think and act solution-focused.
Thoughts and feelings
As helpers, one must maintain connection both to one’s feelings and to one’s thoughts. Feelings help us show compassion, and thoughts enable professional, solution-oriented action. When emotions become too intense, the helper may begin to either overinvolve or underinvolve themselves in the work. Both reactions are attempts to manage feelings of powerlessness, even though their expressions are very different. One could say the overinvolving helper steps closer, perhaps hoping that extra engagement will solve the “problem,” whereas the underinvolving helper steps back, hoping to maintain perspective and avoid being swept away by emotions.
Professionals working in psychotherapy, in particular, need to be highly aware of emotional contagion and empathetic resonance, because therapy deliberately uses the therapist’s own emotions and thoughts as part of the treatment. Whereas an oncologist treats using surgery, chemo, and radiation, a psychotherapist treats through themselves. It is therefore crucial to remain aware of one’s own boundaries. Without this, by the end of the day, a therapist could be filled with the clients’ traumas, grief, loneliness, stress, anxiety, and all the other emotions encountered daily.
I have chosen to use the term CONTACT for the position where a professional is neither over- nor underinvolved but instead properly engaged—fully in contact.
Red–Green–Blue model
The Red–Green–Blue model consists of three fields arranged horizontally. The green field in the middle represents where we feel competent and professionally engaged, where we experience that our skills and knowledge are being used effectively. Our effort makes a difference. The red field to the left of green represents the start of overinvolvement, and the blue field to the right represents underinvolvement. Which side one leans toward under pressure depends on the organization, the team, and the individual.
Being in CONTACT
Det grønne felt i midten handler om at være i kontakThe green field represents being in contact—using empathy to be emotionally affected while trusting that one’s professional skills, judgment, and resources allow influencing the situation appropriately. Contact requires being “aware of oneself” despite the strong impact from the person or situation. Being aware of oneself means maintaining connection with one’s bodily sensations and sense of self—who one is, and what one thinks and feels.
Many high-risk mental professionals have direct contact with the person they are employed to assist and need relevant data to make a professional assessment. This could include, for example, in cases of violence: what happened, who did what, or in health-related situations: current symptoms, medical history, hopes, and fears.
Being overinvolved
To the left of the green field is the red field, representing overinvolvement. Overinvolvement occurs when there is strong emotional identification with the person being helped. This exposes the professional to being affected by feelings of helplessness, frustration, anger, despair, and powerlessness. The professional may become so overwhelmed by emotions that they temporarily lose the ability to think and struggle to regain it afterwards. Overinvolvement typically makes the professional emotionally thin-skinned and vulnerable, which can unconsciously or consciously make the patient/client/citizen unsure if the professional can handle hearing about their pain or distress. Overinvolvement may also result in an overly intimate or personal relationship, which can intimidate the person being helped.
Being underinvolved
To the right of the green field lies the blue field, which represents underinvolvement. This is the opposite reaction a professional may fall into when difficult emotions become overwhelming. Underinvolvement is characterised by emotional distancing from the patient/client/citizen. In the interaction, the professional may appear intellectualising, unaffected, emotionally cold, irritable, or impatient. Underinvolvement can make the professional emotionally thick-skinned and may cause them to appear authoritarian or insensitive. It can lead to situations in which the professional inadvertently violates or dismisses the patient/client/citizen through a detached or overly clinical manner.
Superficially, underinvolvement can be mistaken for control—a status many professionals value and is culturally respected. In reality, underinvolvement, like overinvolvement, indicates the professional has lost balance.
Which side an employee leans toward under pressure depends on organizational culture, role in the team, and personal characteristics.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.